Premiums have risen mostly in step with what health plans spend on care. Asking your benefits advisor to split your renewal into prices, utilization, and pharmacy shows which one is driving your increase.
Total health benefit cost per employee is projected to rise 8.2% on average in 2027, the highest increase since 2003, according to Mercer’s preliminary National Survey of Employer-Sponsored Health Plans, released September 2, 2026.
A study published in JAMA Health Forum two days later helps explain where that money goes. It found that premiums have grown for more than a decade mostly in step with what plans spend on care. If your 2027 renewal came in high, that finding tells you where to aim your questions.
Zack Cooper of Yale University and the National Bureau of Economic Research and Stuart V. Craig of the University of Wisconsin-Madison analyzed data that insurers report to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services from 2011 to 2024. The data covered plans sold to large and small employers, as well as individual marketplace coverage. The study reported three main findings:
Because the insurer’s share is a smaller slice of the bill than it was in 2011, most of a premium increase traces back to the cost of care. The study measured whole markets and can’t prove one caused the other, so your renewal still needs its own breakdown.
Most of a premium pays for your employees’ medical care and prescriptions. Ask your benefits advisor to walk through your renewal one part at a time.
Consider a hypothetical employer whose renewal rose 10%. If two large claims drove most of that, the conversation centers on those cases and how the renewal priced them. If prices rose across most services, the conversation turns to what the plan pays for care.
Once you know which part moved most, ask your advisor what options address it and what each would mean for your employees. They share the bill, paying an average of $1,672 toward single coverage and $7,471 toward family coverage in 2026, according to KFF's 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey.
The study left out self-insured employers. According to KFF, 71% of covered workers were in self-funded plans in 2026.
If your company is self-insured, you pay employees’ claims directly and pay a separate fee to the company that administers the plan, so the study’s markup figures don’t describe your costs. Earlier research cited by Cooper and Craig found that premium trends for self-insured employers have been similar to those of large employers that buy insured plans.
Ask your advisor for the same three-part split of your claims trend, plus the administrator’s fee as a separate line item, showing its change from last year.
This week, ask your benefits advisor to break down your year-over-year cost change by unit prices, utilization, and pharmacy, and show which one moved the most. Start your renewal conversation with that part. If your 2027 renewal is already signed, ask for the same split at your mid-year review, so you head into 2028 knowing where your costs come from. Repeat it every year so you can see whether any changes you made affected the part you targeted.
Content provided by Q4intelligence
Photo by Muhammad